Maximum MAG contamination percentage
Bérénice BatutContamination in Metagenome-Assembled Genomes (MAGs) refers to the presence of sequences from organisms other than the target organism. During de-replication, setting a maximum contamination threshold ensures that only high-quality, representative genomes are retained for downstream analyses.
Why Set a Maximum Contamination Threshold?
-
Data Quality:
High contamination can distort taxonomic classification, functional annotation, and comparative genomics. A contamination threshold ensures that only high-purity MAGs are included.
-
Accurate De-Replication:
Contaminated MAGs may cluster incorrectly, leading to misrepresentation of microbial diversity. A contamination threshold helps ensure that only genuinely similar genomes are grouped together.
-
Functional and Ecological Insights: Low-contamination MAGs provide more reliable insights into microbial functions and ecological roles.
Default and Common Contamination Thresholds
The default contamination threshold in dRep is 25%, which balances inclusivity and quality for general metagenomic studies. However, the choice of threshold depends on the specific goals of your analysis:
| Threshold | Use Case |
|---|---|
| < 5% | Ideal for high-confidence analyses, such as reference genomes or species-level comparisons. |
| < 10% | Suitable for most metagenomic studies, balancing purity and genome diversity. |
| < 25% | Default in dRep, allowing for broader genome inclusion while maintaining reasonable purity. |
-
< 5% Contamination: Used for high-quality MAGs intended for reference databases or detailed functional analyses.
-
< 10% Contamination: A widely adopted threshold for general metagenomic studies, balancing purity and genome retention.
-
< 25% Contamination: The default in dRep, this threshold is more permissive, allowing for a broader range of MAGs while still maintaining reasonable quality.
How to Choose the Right Threshold
-
Study Goals: For high-quality reference databases, use a < 5% threshold. For general analyses, < 10% is recommended. The default 25% in dRep is suitable for exploratory studies.
-
Tool Recommendations: Tools like dRep and CheckM provide contamination estimates and allow you to set thresholds based on your needs.
-
Trade-Offs: Stricter thresholds (e.g., < 5%) will exclude more MAGs, potentially reducing dataset diversity. More permissive thresholds (e.g., < 25%) will retain more MAGs but may include lower-quality genomes.
Setting a maximum contamination threshold is essential for ensuring the quality of de-replicated MAGs. The default threshold in dRep is 25%, but you can adjust it based on your study goals and the trade-offs between purity and genome retention. By carefully selecting this threshold, you can optimize your MAG dataset for accurate downstream analyses.